Guide · Growth

Direct bookings vs OTAs: the commission maths for resorts and homestays

What MakeMyTrip, Booking.com, Agoda and Airbnb cost a resort or homestay, what a direct booking costs instead, and how to shift the mix.

By Aaryavar, Founder, Restronaut

10 min readFigures checked

Share

Direct bookings vs OTAs: the commission maths for resorts and homestays

restronaut.in

Direct bookings vs OTAs: the commission maths for resorts and homestays

Direct bookings vs OTAs: the commission maths for resorts and homestays What MakeMyTrip, Booking.com, Agoda and Airbnb cost a resort or homestay, what a direct booking costs instead, and how to shift the mix. https://restronaut.in/restronomics/articles/direct-bookings-vs-otas-resorts?utm_source=whatsapp&utm_medium=social

On this page

Key takeaways

  • Most OTAs do not publish a commission rate. Read your own contract and your monthly statements, and work out the effective rate after promotions, programmes and GST on the commission.
  • Airbnb is the exception. Most hosts on its single-fee structure pay 15.5% of the booking subtotal, and hotels and serviced apartments must use that structure.
  • In 2022 the CCI ordered MakeMyTrip-Goibibo to drop wide price parity and room availability parity from its hotel contracts. The appeal is still pending, but MakeMyTrip says it has complied with those directions in the meantime.
  • A direct booking is not free. Budget for the booking engine, a payment gateway at around 2% plus GST, and whatever perk you offer. Google's free booking links cost nothing per click.
  • Keep the OTAs for first-time guests and move repeat guests, referrals and enquiries to your own channel. Track direct share, cost per direct booking and net revenue per room-night each month.

An OTA booking costs a negotiated commission most platforms do not publish, plus GST on it and any promotions you join; Airbnb takes 15.5% from most hosts. A direct booking costs a booking-engine fee, payment charges and your perks. It usually nets more per room-night, but only on guests who would have found you anyway.

What do the OTAs actually charge?

Mostly, they don't say in public. Rates for MakeMyTrip, Goibibo, Booking.com and Agoda are set in each property's contract, so the numbers below are the few that a platform, a filing, a regulator or a named report has put on record. Treat each one as a data point, not a benchmark.

PlatformWhat is on recordSource
AirbnbMost hosts on the single-fee structure pay 15.5% of the booking subtotal; the rest typically pay 14% to 16%. Hotels, serviced apartments and hosts using property management software must use this structureAirbnb Help Centre
Airbnb (split fee, being phased out)Host pays 3%; the guest pays a separate 14.1% to 16.5%Airbnb Help Centre
MakeMyTrip-GoibiboAfter a week-long boycott by about 270 Ahmedabad hotels, the group agreed to cap commission at 22% for that city (reported January 2019)Online Marketplaces
MakeMyTrip-GoibiboA 2026 short-seller report claims commissions fell from about 35% to as low as 18% as Booking.com and Agoda competed. MakeMyTrip called it "a typical short-seller report"Business Today
Booking.comNo public rate for India. A Goa hotelier told MediaNama he pays 30% commission to OTAs for visibilityMediaNama
AgodaWe could not open a published rate; check the contracted compensation in your own extranet—

One regulator has looked hard at the level itself. In May 2025, Switzerland's Price Supervisor ruled that Booking.com's commission rates for Swiss hotels were excessive and ordered an average cut of "almost a quarter", for three years. Booking.com could appeal (Swiss Price Supervisor). That ruling covers Switzerland only. Nothing similar exists in India.

Three things push your real rate above the headline:

  • Promotions and visibility programmes. Deals, member discounts and paid-ranking programmes either take a cut from your rate or add to the commission. Each platform's extranet shows which you have joined.
  • GST on the commission. The OTA bills GST on its fee. Ask your accountant whether you can claim it back at your room tariff; if you cannot, it is a straight cost.
  • Cancellations and no-shows. Read how your contract treats them. They change the effective rate on the rooms you actually fill.

The only reliable number is your own. Take last quarter's OTA statements, add commission, GST on it, programme fees and any discounts you funded, and divide by gross room revenue from that OTA.

What did the CCI say about parity clauses?

It said the wide ones were illegal for a dominant platform. On 19 October 2022 the Competition Commission of India ruled on complaints by the Federation of Hotel & Restaurant Associations of India (FHRAI), FabHotels and Treebo. It found that MakeMyTrip-Goibibo (MMT-Go) was dominant in the market for online intermediation services for booking hotels in India, and that it had abused that position (Khaitan & Co).

Two clauses were at the centre:

  • Price parity. Hotels could not sell a room for less on another platform or on their own website than on MMT-Go.
  • Room availability parity. Hotels could not refuse rooms to MMT-Go while selling them through any other OTA (LiveLaw).

The CCI also found the arrangement that led to FabHotels, Treebo and independent hotels being delisted from MMT-Go was anti-competitive. It fined MMT-Go ₹223.48 crore and OYO ₹168.88 crore (LiveLaw). It told MMT-Go to drop price and room availability parity, to give hotels fair and non-discriminatory access, and to show travellers clearly when a property was not available on the platform.

The order separated "wide" parity, which covers every channel including other OTAs, from "narrow" parity, which only stops a hotel undercutting the OTA on its own website. Narrow parity was treated as potentially justifiable in some circumstances (Khaitan & Co).

The case is not over. MakeMyTrip's latest annual filing says it appealed to the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) in November 2022, deposited 10% of the penalty, and has had enforcement of the rest stayed. It also says it has complied with the CCI's behavioural directions while the appeal is pending (MakeMyTrip Form 20-F, FY2026).

Hoteliers say the clauses have not disappeared. In August 2025, MediaNama quoted a Goibibo agreement requiring hotels to "maintain rate parity and room availability parity" across channels and the hotel itself, and Booking.com wording asking partners for "the same or better rates, conditions & availability" (MediaNama). A 2026 short-seller report claimed MakeMyTrip still scores hotels on parity and cuts visibility for those that break it; MakeMyTrip dismissed the report (Business Today).

What this means for you: read your current contract, clause by clause. If it binds your own website's price, ask the OTA in writing how that squares with the CCI order. This is not legal advice; take a lawyer's view before you change rates on the strength of it.

What does a direct booking cost instead?

Less per booking, but not nothing. You pay for software, payments and the marketing that brings the guest to you.

Booking engine. Two pricing models are common in India. Some charge a share of each booking: AxisRooms advertises a commission of 4–5% on its booking engine (AxisRooms). Others charge a subscription: DJUBO describes a "commission-free direct booking widget" in packages whose prices it does not publish (DJUBO). A per-booking fee suits a small homestay with few direct bookings. A flat fee gets cheaper per booking as your direct share grows. Ask every vendor for a written quote at your room count.

One point of fairness: some direct-booking tools belong to the OTAs you are trying to rely on less. MakeMyTrip holds a majority stake in Simplotel, which sells technology to help hotels win direct bookings (MakeMyTrip Form 20-F). That doesn't make the product worse, but you should know who owns your stack.

Payment gateway. Razorpay's standard rate is a 2% platform fee on domestic cards, UPI, netbanking and wallets, plus 18% GST on that fee, and up to 3% on international cards (Razorpay). Other gateways price differently; compare before you sign.

Google's free booking links. Google shows a hotel's own booking link and rate next to OTA prices in hotel search, and says "there's no cost for clicks on free booking links" (Google Hotel Center Help). Bids do not affect their ranking. Google ranks them on signals such as value to the user, landing page experience and price accuracy. If your booking engine or channel manager is a Google connectivity partner, it can usually set this up for you (Google Hotel Center Help). Ask your vendor first.

Google Hotel Ads and metasearch. These are paid. Google's current hotel campaign bid strategies are Target ROAS, Enhanced CPC, manual cost-per-click and CPC% (a percentage of the nightly room price per click). Google is retiring its commission-based options (Google Ads Help). So you pay per click whether or not the guest books. Set a monthly cap and measure cost per booking, not clicks.

Your perk. If you offer direct guests breakfast, a late checkout or a small discount, count it as a cost of the channel.

Worked example: 100 room-nights, OTA vs direct

These numbers are illustrative. They are chosen to show the maths, not quoted from any platform, so put your own rates in.

Assume a 12-room resort sells 100 room-nights at an average ₹5,000 a night before tax, so ₹5,00,000 in room revenue either way. On the OTA, we assume an 18% commission, GST at 18% on that commission which you cannot claim back, and a 5% promotion you fund. Direct, we assume a booking engine at 4% per booking, a gateway at 2% plus 18% GST, complimentary breakfast for two at a cost of ₹300 a night, and ₹15,000 spent on paid search to bring these guests in.

Line100 nights via OTA100 nights direct
Room revenue₹5,00,000₹5,00,000
Promotion you fund (5%)₹25,000—
Commission (18% on ₹4,75,000)₹85,500—
GST on commission (18%)₹15,390—
Booking engine (4%)—₹20,000
Payment gateway (2% + GST)—₹11,800
Breakfast perk—₹30,000
Paid search—₹15,000
Total channel cost₹1,25,890₹76,800
Net room revenue₹3,74,110₹4,23,200
Net per room-night₹3,741₹4,232

Direct comes out ₹49,090 ahead on 100 nights, about ₹491 a night. Two cautions. First, most of that saving holds only if the direct guest was one you would have got anyway, such as a repeat guest, a referral or someone who already found you on Instagram. A first-time guest who discovered you on an OTA may not have booked at all without it. Second, the gap narrows if your perk is generous or your paid search is inefficient. At ₹40,000 of paid search for the same 100 nights, the direct advantage falls to ₹24,090.

If your booking engine is a flat subscription instead, divide the monthly fee by your direct room-nights to get the per-night cost, and compare again.

How do you shift the mix without leaving the OTAs?

Treat OTAs as the shop window and your own channel as the till for guests who already know you. STAAH's ranking of 2025 booking channels for its Indian partner hotels put its own direct booking engine fifth, behind GoMMT, Agoda, Booking.com and Cleartrip (Indian Television). That is a vendor's claim about its own customers, but it fits the pattern: OTAs still lead, and direct is a channel you build next to them.

  1. Make the website bookable. A live booking engine with real availability, on mobile, in three taps or fewer. An enquiry form is not a booking engine.
  2. Turn on Google's free booking links through your engine or channel manager, and keep your Google listing's photos, rates and policies current. Our Google Business Profile guide is written for restaurants, but the profile basics apply to any property.
  3. Give a reason to book direct that does not undercut your OTA rate if your contract still has a parity clause. Breakfast, a room upgrade on availability, early check-in or a free cancellation window are common choices.
  4. Use WhatsApp for enquiries, and close with a link. Reply fast, then send the booking-engine link rather than taking bank transfers by hand. You keep the payment record and the guest gets an instant confirmation.
  5. Own the repeat guest. Collect consent and contact details at check-in. Send a note before the next season with a returning-guest offer. A guest who came through an OTA once is the cheapest direct booking you will ever get.
  6. Work the referral. Ask happy guests to send friends to your website, not the app.
  7. Keep OTA content good. Your OTA listing is often where a guest first sees you, and many will then look you up. Weak photos there cost you direct bookings too.

The same logic runs through our piece on what Swiggy and Zomato really cost a restaurant: pay the platform for discovery, and move the regulars to your own channel.

What should you track each month?

A handful of numbers, from your property management system, channel manager and OTA statements:

  • Direct share: direct room-nights as a share of all room-nights.
  • Effective OTA rate, per OTA: everything you paid the platform divided by gross room revenue from it.
  • Cost per direct booking: engine, gateway, perks and ads, divided by direct bookings.
  • Net revenue per room-night, by channel: the figure the worked example ends on.
  • Repeat-guest share: how many direct bookings came from past guests.
  • Free booking link clicks and bookings, if your engine reports them.
  • Cancellation rate by channel, since a cheap channel with high cancellations may not be cheap.

Review them every month, and compare like seasons. A monsoon month against a December month tells you nothing.

Checklist

  • Pull last quarter's statements from every OTA and calculate your effective rate for each.
  • Read each OTA contract for price parity and room availability parity clauses; get a lawyer's view if your website price is bound.
  • Put a mobile booking engine on your website with live availability.
  • Ask your engine or channel manager to switch on Google's free booking links.
  • Choose one direct-booking perk and cost it per night.
  • Set a monthly cap on paid search or metasearch, and measure cost per booking.
  • Move WhatsApp and phone enquiries to the booking link.
  • Capture repeat-guest contact details with consent, and plan one pre-season message.
  • Track direct share, effective OTA rate, cost per direct booking and net revenue per room-night every month.
  • Revisit the numbers after one full season before you cut any OTA.

How we made this

We read MakeMyTrip's FY2026 Form 20-F, the Swiss Price Supervisor's Booking.com ruling, Airbnb's and Google's own help pages, Razorpay's published pricing, two booking-engine vendors' pages, legal and press coverage of the CCI's 2022 order, and press reports that quote named commission figures. AI tools helped gather sources and draft; the editor checks every figure against its source before publishing. Restronomics has no commercial relationship with any company named here. Our editorial standards

Sources

  1. MakeMyTrip Limited, Form 20-F for the fiscal year ended 31 March 2026, MakeMyTrip Limited (US SEC filing). Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  2. Excessive commission rates by Booking.com – Price Supervisor orders reduction (21 May 2025), Office of the Price Supervisor, Swiss Federal Department of Economic Affairs. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  3. Airbnb service fees, Airbnb Help Centre. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  4. About hotel free booking links, Google Hotel Center Help. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  5. Connect with more travelers using free booking links, Google Hotel Center Help. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  6. Bid strategies for hotel campaigns, Google Ads Help. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  7. Pricing (India), Razorpay. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  8. Hotel booking engine, AxisRooms. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  9. DJUBO product reference (llms-full.txt), DJUBO. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  10. Make My Trip, Go-Ibibo and Oyo penalised for Rs. 392.36 crores by CCI for anti-competitive practices, LiveLaw. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  11. CCI imposes penalties on Indian OTA MakeMyTrip and budget hotel franchise OYO, Khaitan & Co. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  12. India should learn from the EU's Booking.com price parity lawsuit, MediaNama. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  13. Hotelier protests drowned out by MakeMyTrip success, Online Marketplaces. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  14. MakeMyTrip padded profits, misled customers, allowed 'bad actor' hotels in its platform: Report, Business Today. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.
  15. STAAH names India's top hotel booking channels of 2025, Indian Television. Accessed 25 Oct 2026.

Restaurant Industry Intelligence

Data-driven insights, trends, and analysis for food & beverage professionals.

Subscribe Free